ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) implementations are essential for streamlining business processes, but they often become notorious for spiraling out of control and turning into costly money pits. However, it doesn’t have to be this way. With proper planning, realistic budgeting, and effective project management, organizations can avoid common pitfalls that lead to budget overruns and failed implementations. Let’s explore how to ensure that your ERP implementation stays on track and within budget.
The Problem: Unrealistic Cost Estimates
One of the biggest challenges organizations face at the start of any ERP project is an unrealistic cost estimate. While it’s easy to budget for software costs, other implementation-related expenses are often overlooked, and this leads to significant budget overruns.
Initially, software vendors typically provide an implementation cost estimate, which often only includes the direct costs of the software itself. These figures are relatively easy to predict because they’re based on the software modules and the number of subscriptions you’re purchasing. However, what vendors often fail to address adequately are the hidden costs involved in a full-scale ERP implementation, such as:
- Technical implementation costs: These include the resources needed for system configuration, customizations, and integrations with existing systems. The scope and complexity of these tasks often get underestimated, leading to unforeseen costs.
- Data migration: Migrating data from legacy systems to a new ERP system can be a complex, time-consuming, and costly process. This is often one of the biggest hidden costs that organizations overlook.
- Training and change management: Implementing a new ERP system requires substantial investment in training employees and managing the organizational change. Neglecting to budget for these areas can cause delays and lead to additional costs.
- Testing and post-implementation support: Many organizations underestimate the amount of testing required to ensure the new system works as expected. Post-implementation support is also necessary to address issues that arise once the system is live.
Without factoring these in, you may find yourself facing significant financial strain down the road. To avoid this, it’s essential to account for these additional costs during the initial budgeting process. A thorough analysis of the total cost of ownership (TCO) should include not just the software but also these auxiliary costs to get a clearer picture of the full project cost.
The Role of Assumptions in Budgeting
Beyond hidden costs, unrealistic assumptions are often a driving factor behind ERP budget overruns. ERP vendors typically base their cost estimates on a set of assumptions about how the project will unfold. For example, vendors might assume:
- That data migration will be straightforward: However, this often isn’t the case, as data might need to be cleaned, validated, and transformed before being migrated to the new system.
- That key internal resources will be available: Vendors might assume that the organization’s team members will be fully available and committed to the project. However, internal resources are often pulled in multiple directions, leading to delays and cost overruns.
- That project milestones will be met without major roadblocks: ERP projects often face unforeseen challenges, such as integration complexities or unexpected user resistance. Vendors might assume that these issues will be minimal or non-existent, leading to unrealistic timelines and budgets.
These assumptions can drastically impact the project’s cost and timeline. It’s crucial to challenge these assumptions early in the process. If you don’t fully understand the impact of these assumptions on your overall budget, it can lead to significant surprises down the road.
By working with an independent advisor who is not tied to the vendor, you can gain a more objective perspective on these assumptions and understand how they could affect your project. Having a clear understanding of these potential issues will give you a much more accurate budget from the outset.
Balancing Internal Resources with External Consultants
Another key factor in ERP cost overruns is the imbalance between internal resources and external consultants. Many organizations struggle to allocate enough internal resources to the project, leading them to rely heavily on external consultants. This can lead to several issues:
- Higher costs: Consultants often charge premium rates, and over-relying on them can quickly inflate the budget.
- Slower decision-making: When internal team members aren’t fully involved in the project, decisions tend to take longer, which leads to delays. This, in turn, can increase costs as the project stretches beyond its original timeline.
- Less ownership: When external consultants drive most of the project, internal teams may not feel as invested in its success. This lack of ownership can lead to suboptimal results and missed opportunities for improvement.
The key is to strike the right balance. Internal resources should be committed to the project, taking responsibility for key tasks, decision-making, and change management. External consultants should play a supporting role, providing expertise in areas where the organization lacks experience but not driving the entire project.
Before starting the project, take the time to assess your internal resources. Do you have the necessary skills and bandwidth to handle the project? If not, make sure you hire or allocate resources ahead of time. If you don’t have the internal resources ready, it might be better to delay the start of the project until you do, rather than rushing to bring in external consultants who may end up costing you more in the long run.
Managing the Project and Staying on Budget
Once you’ve set a realistic budget and established clear expectations, the next crucial step is managing that budget. This requires proper project governance, accountability, and a project management office (PMO) to oversee the entire process.
One of the biggest mistakes organizations make is relying on the same technical vendors and consultants to manage the budget. This is problematic because vendors have a vested interest in extending the project timeline to generate more revenue. To avoid this, it’s crucial to appoint an internal project manager or PMO who can oversee the entire project and ensure that costs stay within budget.
A strong PMO is responsible for coordinating internal resources, external vendors, and consultants to ensure alignment with the budget and timeline. They must also manage changes in scope, as any scope creep can cause budget overruns.
It’s also important to implement regular checkpoints throughout the project to assess progress against the budget. Regularly reviewing the project’s budget and timeline helps identify issues early and gives you the opportunity to adjust the plan before it spirals out of control.
The Hidden Danger: Unrealistic Expectations
While poor budgeting and a lack of resources can contribute to ERP cost overruns, the real root cause often lies in unrealistic expectations. This is especially true when organizations are overly optimistic about how quickly the implementation can be completed.
For example, a vendor might promise to complete the implementation in 12 months, but the reality is that it might take 18 months due to unforeseen challenges, changes in scope, or delays in decision-making. If you’ve budgeted for a 12-month timeline, the sudden extension of the project timeline can not only add additional time but also increase the overall cost due to the extended involvement of external vendors and consultants.
It’s crucial to set realistic expectations from the start. Understand that ERP projects rarely go exactly as planned. Factors such as changes in business requirements, vendor delays, and internal resource constraints can all impact the timeline and budget. Setting a realistic timeline and factoring in potential delays can help you avoid unpleasant surprises.
Conclusion: Avoiding the Money Pit
ERP implementations don’t have to be money pits. By ensuring you have a realistic budget, challenging assumptions, balancing internal and external resources, and implementing strong project governance, you can steer your project toward success. The key is to set accurate expectations, be proactive in managing costs, and continuously monitor the project to stay within budget.
One of the most important steps to ensuring the success of your ERP implementation is recognizing the full scope of costs, including hidden and often overlooked expenses. By addressing these early, you can set your project on the right path.
How Can We Help with your Business Transformation: people-first
At Third Stage Consulting, we are passionate about empowering organizations to successfully navigate the complexities of digital transformation. Whether you’re embarking on a new transformation journey or aiming to optimize your current processes, our expert team is committed to providing comprehensive support throughout every phase. From initial strategy development to execution and beyond, we work closely with you to ensure that your transformation goals are met efficiently and effectively.
